La Jolla Seals Facing Foreclosure?

Geoffrey Schiering by Geoffrey Schiering

Almost everyone who has visited La Jolla in recent years has taken time to stroll past the Children’s Pool to take in the sight of waves crashing against the sea wall, and to watch seals and sea lions bask in the sun. The seals have become a fixture in the area for years, as more than 200 seals currently live at the cove. There are few places in San Diego other than SeaWorld where tourists and San Diego residents alike are pretty much guaranteed to enjoy the opportunity to have such a close encounter with seals. This may soon change.

There has been a recent movement to remove the seals from their La Jolla homes to parts unknown. Pollution is the ostensible reason for the removal, with bacteria levels blamed on the seal feces. In May, the City of San Diego announced that it would begin chasing the seals away to restore the Children’s Pool to a beach habitat strictly for humans. The plan is to set up an amplified speaker system to broadcast the sound of dogs barking. Seals are afraid of dogs, so it is hoped that the canine cacophony will sufficiently encourage the seals to move out of La Jolla and find a different habitat.

There are several problems with the planned seal unsettling. First, the estimated cost of the subwoofer system is $689,000 per year. Almost three quarters of a million dollars to keep 200 seals from lying in the sand, comes to $3,445 per seal per year ($20,670 for a family of six). In an era of cash-strapped city finances, it hardly seems right to spend money in this fashion. The local homeless shelters could use the money in a much more effective manner.

Second, assuming the seals are dislodged from the Children’s Pool, where is it likely that they will go next? Perhaps the City of San Diego is hoping that the seals will pull up a rock at Del Mar or Solana Beach? Will we then be passing the buck to the smaller incorporated cities to come up with their own solution? Or maybe the seals will move south to Mission Bay or Pacific beach homes, or even downtown to the San Diego harbor. Will we then set up another $3/4 Million program to move the seals from those areas in a few years? Are we hoping that they will eventually learn Spanish and move south of the border to Tijuana or perhaps to the beach tourista cities of Rosarito or Ensenada?

Third, the plan to remove the seals is not popular with San Diego residents. A poll taken by the San Diego company Competitive Edge in June asked 504 randomly selected adults for their opinions. 64% of the respondents said that they are opposed to moving the seals. 47% are strongly opposed. 25% are in favor of the removal plan, while only 16% are strongly in favor of removing the seals. The margin of error is only 5%, so clearly there is insufficient public support of the project to invest the money required for the removal scheme.

Finally, the seal removal is expected to hurt La Jolla businesses. The Competitive Edge also found that up to 70,000 people annually would stop visiting La Jolla if the seals were not there to attract them. La Jolla business owners would certainly feel the bite, not just hear the bark, if the removal plan is enacted.

There are plenty of other beaches in La Jolla where owners of La Jolla homes can join San Diego residents and tourists for a swim. Why stir the soup in the Children’s Pool?

9 Comments to La Jolla Seals Facing Foreclosure?

Comments

  • David says:

    Leave the seals alone! They are a delight and we are fortunate to have the opportunity to enjoy them. There certainly are plenty of other beaches in San Diego where the people can go who want to take a swim.

  • Jan Goldsmith says:

    A judge ordered the City of San Diego to develop a plan to remove the seals. The City opposed this, but complied because it was a court order.

    The City is seeking state legislation to change the terms of a state trust which was the basis for the judge’s order. If the legislation is enacted, the reason for the order will be eliminated and we will ask the court to vacate its order. Unless and until that legislation is passed and the court vacates its order, the City must do what the judge orders us to do.

    The legislation is SB 428 carried by State Senator Christine Kehoe. You can view the bill and its analysis at
    http://www.assembly.ca.gov/acs/acsframeset2text.htm.

    That site will also give you the names and contact info for members of the legislature should you want to make your views known.

    Thank you.

    Jan Goldsmith
    San Diego City Attorney

    • Geoff Geoff says:

      Thanks for the clarification Jan. The court order seems ludicrous, and I’m glad to know that the city also opposes it. I must have misinterpreted a report in the San Diego Union Tribune, or else it was shoddy reporting. Best wishes with your legislative effort to change the terms. And Happy Independence Day!

    • r. fawell says:

      REASONS FOR REMOVAL OF SEALS 1. THEY ARE ATTRACTING DANGEROUS GREAT WHITE SHARKS –FIRST VICTIM WAS DAVE MARTIN OF SOLANA BEACH. THE ENTIRE SEAL POPULATION MUST BE CULLED IMMEDIATELY IN CALIFORNIA. 2. MRS SCRIPPS BUILT THE BREAKWATER FOR CHILDREN TO HAVE A SAFE BEACH EXPERIENCE. 3. WHEN MORE SHARK ATTACKS TAKE PLACE THE TOURIST REVENUE IN LA JOLLA WILL TAKE A BIG HIT. 4. THE SMELL FROM THE SEALS IS ALREADY CAUSING TOURISTS TO CHOOSE DEL MAR OVER LA JOLLA. 5. THE FIGHTS BETWEEN FINATICAL CONSERVATIONISTS MAY LEAD TO VIOLENCE AND EVEN GOD FORBID–MURDER.

      • Geoff Geoff says:

        You’ve made very good points here. The shark attack was certainly a tragedy, and hopefully will not happen again. If the seals were moved from the La Jolla Children’s Pool would they simply go somewhere else in the area? Is the situation that out of natural balance that sharks are coming to an area where they would normally not go? Hopefully there is some research on being done at Scripps on that issue.

  • dames kleding says:

    great points altogether, you just received a brand new reader. What might you recommend about your post that you simply made a few days ago? Any certain?

  • col3 says:

    Excellent site. Lots of helpful info here. I am sending it to a few buddies ans also sharing in delicious. And naturally, thank you in your sweat!

  • Onesie says:

    Hello my friend! I wish to say that this article is awesome, great written and include almost all important infos. I’d like to peer extra posts like this .

  • First off I want to say awesome blog! I had a quick
    question in which I’d like to ask if you don’t mind.
    I was curious to know how you center yourself and clear
    your mind prior to writing. I’ve had trouble clearing my thoughts in getting my thoughts out. I truly do take pleasure in writing however it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes are generally wasted just trying to figure out how to begin. Any recommendations or tips? Many thanks!

Trackbacks/Pingbacks